Damn you, moisture!
In the woodworking, furniture making and DIY world, moisture is just about always a bad word.
At least, if there’s too much of it, which is why I’m mentioning the “M” word now. Whether it’s moisture causing a wet basement, moisture in between two window panes or moisture left on a piece of furniture that damages the finish, the result is somewhere between bad and awful.
I’m dealing with a more run-of-the-mill moisture problem, and honestly, it’s one that’s more embarrassing than it is awful. If you read my column two weeks ago about the simple writing surface I made for myself, you’ll know the drawers were the main challenge. It was the design of the drawer faces that pushed my buttons, but I persevered, and I like to think I won the design battle. What I should have given more thought to were the gaps between the drawer sides and the runners. I built the drawers in April, when it was still far from humid. Now, we’ve had a few days of warmth and humidity and my drawers are sticking. For a seasoned woodworker, that’s just embarrassing.
Wood moves
One rule I tell all my students, as well as anyone else who will listen, is that wood moves. It’s just about impossible to stop that from happening. Furniture makers have a few tricks up their sleeves to engineer a piece of furniture so seasonal changes in humidity don’t affect the parts of a piece of furniture (especially the moving parts, like doors and drawers). Grain orientation is one of them. Flat cut wood moves about twice as much as quarter cut wood. But I overlooked grain orientation when building the drawers that frustrated me so much about six weeks ago. I had my eye on the design portion of the build, and didn’t pay enough attention to the (flat cut) material I used for the drawers.
When I installed the project, the drawers fit perfectly, if I do say so myself. The gaps around the four sides of each drawer front were even and a nice width. Then it got humid. The drawers quickly swelled, almost locking inside the two drawer boxes they were housed in.
The lower drawer runs on the bottom of the drawer box, but the upper drawer runs on a pair of maple strips that were let into the inner face of each drawer box gable. Both upper and lower drawers in both drawer boxes were either snug or nearly impossible to pry open.
You should be ashamed, Rob
I hung my head in shame, headed to the shop and brought home a block plane. As shavings fell to the living room floor, I inched closer and closer to a properly fitting set of drawers. I didn’t want to take too much off, as that would only mean a loose, unsightly fit come February. As they sit now, the drawers are moving freely. I haven’t brought my block plane back to the shop yet, as June has only just begun. These drawers have the entire summer to soak up moisture and expand to the point of more frustration and embarrassment on behalf of their humbled maker.
Excuses, excuses
You’d think over 30 years in the furniture making industry would have taught me the main rule in furniture making; wood moves, so engineer properly. In my defense, it’s been a strange spring. The heat hasn’t really hit until just the past few days, so we haven’t had our air conditioning on at all. Air conditioning units not only cool the air, but remove humidity from it, meaning wood has less of it to soak up. But this spring has seen not only relatively low temperatures, but a fair bit of rain and damp weather.
I’m now keenly watching, and drawing drawers open and closed, while I test out the effects our air conditioning unit has on wood. A slight shave might be in order, but I’m hoping we’re done making shavings in the living room.
Workshop moisture meter
A few years ago, I sliced about 3/8″ off the length of a small pine table top. Rather than pitch it in the garbage, I hung it on the wall. One of its edges is perfectly straight. I wrote the overall length of the strip and the date onto it, so I could compare its size down the road. It’s 3/16″ longer in the summer than in the winter. I use it to show clients and students how much wood moves. I should study it myself once in a while.
How about you?
Have you had any challenges with doors or drawers swelling in the summer months? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.
Yet another comment
Speaking of the comments section, last week I posted 11 macro images of woodworking and DIY items. We got a bunch of good guesses by five readers, though they only got between two and six of the items correct, out of the 11 posted. I also got some emails with answers. I posted the correct answers in that column, in the comments section, along with images of the 11 tools / items at the end of that updated column.
Shop Moisture Meter
This simple offcut has a lot of exposed end grain, which quickly accepts and gives off moisture when humidity levels change, giving me a relatively good idea of how much humidity is in the air at a certain time of the year.
Hi Tim.
I think that was enough time for the lumber to acclimate. Could be another issue here, though I’m not sure what it is. You could send me a few photos of the top and cracked area if you’d like.
Biscuits likely aren’t the answer. They add a small amount of strength, but a good glue joint is stronger than the wood itself. Maybe your glue was bad. Or maybe one of those joints wasn’t great. Maybe another reason.
Hopefully I can help you out.
I built a kitchen table out of clear red cedar a couple of years ago using 1 1/2″ boards, stored in my shop for probably 4 years. I thought that this length of time would assure me of a problem-free build, but last spring, my beautiful table cracked down the middle at a glued joint even though I had put end pieces on, fastened only at the middle of the table, thinking this method would protect. I guess, in retrospect, that I should maybe have used biscuits in the glued joints! Thanks for the article!
I don’t build much furniture but since our basement flooded a couple of months ago (ice storm + power outage = no sump pump) we’ve been running a dehumidifier full time and rotating it between rooms every day. At first it was drawing almost 2 gallons of water per day out of the air but now it is down to half of that. Anyway my point is that except for the first couple of days when there was a lot of wet stuff down there it hasn’t felt particularly damp so you can’t go by how the air feels.
And yes, reading Carl’s article about dehumidifiers is next on my list.
I feel this pain acutely. Sometimes I forget as you have done and sometimes I just ignore it and both have the same result.
I’m building an inset wall niche of walnut. I have a lot of it around so I’m using solid. The bottom has inset doors to be 3/4” thick, 30” long and 7 1/4 “ wide. It’s tempting to try a solid door as the width is pretty narrow – however to have lovely face grain mirrored – well that’s the worst choice for movement.
So I will make my own veneers with 1/8 slices and 1/2” Baltic birch. The upside is no one sees end grain on ends with the doors open